HANSARD
99/00-58

HOUSE OF ASSEMBLY

DEBATES AND PROCEEDINGS

Speaker: Honourable Murray Scott

Published by Order of the Legislature by Hansard Reporting Services and printed by the Queen's Printer.

Available on INTERNET at http://www.gov.ns.ca/legi/hansard/

Annual Subscriptions Available from the Office of the Speaker. Single copies sold at the Nova Scotia Government Book Store.

First Session

WEDNESDAY, MAY 3, 2000

TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE
PRESENTING AND READING PETITIONS:
Educ.: Cuts - Oppose, Mr. J. Holm 4867
Educ.: Cuts - Oppose, Ms. E. O'Connell 4868
Educ.: Cuts - Oppose, Ms. Maureen MacDonald 4868
Educ.: Cuts - Oppose, Ms. Maureen MacDonald 4868
Educ.: Cuts - Oppose, Mr. Robert Chisholm 4868
Econ. Dev. - Min.: Budget - Silence, Mr. F. Corbett 4869
Educ.: Cuts - Oppose, Mr. W. Estabrooks 4869
Educ.: Cuts - Oppose, Mr. D. Dexter 4869
Educ.: Cuts - Oppose, Mr. John MacDonell 4869
Educ.: Cuts - Oppose, Mr. J. Pye 4869
Educ.: Cuts - Oppose, Mr. J. Holm 4870
Educ. - Students: Special Needs - Support, Ms. E. O'Connell 4870
Educ.: Cuts - Oppose, Mr. K. Deveaux 4870
Health - Environmental Illness: Treatment Clinic - Support,
Mr. D. Dexter 4871
SPEAKER'S RULING ON PREVIOUS POINT OF ORDER:
"Deceived" - Use (Point of Order by Mr. J. Pye p. 4851)
Ruling - Unparliamentary 4871
STATEMENTS BY MINISTERS:
Abor. Affs. - Sergeant-at-Arms (Mr. Noel Knockwood): Job Performance -
Congrats., Hon. M. Baker 4871
GOVERNMENT NOTICES OF MOTION:
Res. 1698, Tourism - Prince of Fundy Cruise Lines: Service (30 Yrs.) -
Congrats., Hon. Rodney MacDonald 4872
Vote - Affirmative 4873
Res. 1699, Health - Multi-Organ Transplant Progs.:
Dr. Allan MacDonald & Dr. Vivian McAlister - Thank,
Hon. J. Muir 4873
Vote - Affirmative 4873
Res. 1700, Tourism - Yar. Co. Tourist Assoc.: Dedication - Recognize,
Hon. Rodney MacDonald 4874
Vote - Affirmative 4874
Res. 1701, Health: World Asthma Day - Recognize, Hon. J. Muir 4874
Vote - Affirmative 4875
NOTICES OF MOTION:
Res. 1702, Educ. - Schools: Equipment Removal -
Performance Recognize, Mr. P. MacEwan 4875
Res. 1703, Educ. - Kingston School: Birthday Unhappy (Student) -
Explain (Min.), Ms. E. O'Connell 4876
Res. 1704, Petroleum Dir. - Offshore: Promotion (Premier) - Commend,
Mr. K. Morash 4877
Vote - Affirmative 4877
Res. 1705, PC Backbench MLAs - Educ. Budget (2000-01):
Advice (PC Candidate) - Take, Mr. Manning MacDonald 4877
Res. 1706, PC MLAs (Anna. V.): Mascot (Chicken) - Adopt,
Mr. D. Dexter 4878
Res. 1707, NDP (N.S.) - Promises: Consequences Gov'ts.
(NDP [Ont. & B.C.]) - View, Mr. F. Chipman 4879
Res. 1708, Culture - Bob Homme (Friendly Giant-CBC), Death of:
Contributions - Recognize, Mr. K. Deveaux 4880
Vote - Affirmative 4881
Res. 1709, Volunteerism: Kentville & Area Red Cross - Recognize,
Mr. M. Parent 4881
Vote - Affirmative 4881
Res. 1710, Tourism - Peggy's Cove: Rock Patrol Cut - Reconsidered,
Mr. W. Estabrooks 4882
Res. 1711, Educ. - School Equipment: Non-Lavish - Recognize,
Ms. E. O'Connell 4882
Res. 1712, Volunteerism: Oakwood Terrace Ctr. (Dart.) -
Recognize, Mr. T. Olive 4883
Vote - Affirmative 4883
Res. 1713, Econ. Dev. - Anna. V. Peat Moss (Endres Family-Berwick):
Success - Congrats., Mr. J. Carey 4884
Vote - Affirmative 4884
Res. 1714, CBC - 1st Edition & Maritimes Tonight - Maintain,
Ms. M. McGrath 4884
Vote - Affirmative 4885
Res. 1715, Educ. - Youth Abroad Team (Cdn.): Aaron Holdway
(Fall River) - Trek Congrats., Hon. P. Christie 4885
Vote - Affirmative 4886
Res. 1716, Sports - Chess Challenge (Cdn., Maritime & N.S.):
Students (Lun. Co.) - Congrats., Mr. D. Downe 4886
Vote - Affirmative 4887
Res. 1717, Sports - Motocross (Truro Arenacross 2000): Organizers -
Congrats., (By Hon. J. Muir) Mr. B. Taylor 4887
Vote - Affirmative 4887
Res. 1718, RCL F.E. Butler Branch No. 44 (Chester): Contributions -
Salute, (By Mr. W. Dooks) Hon. J. Chataway 4888
Vote - Affirmative 4888
Res. 1719, Educ. - School Equipment: Removal Rescinded -
Lesson Recognize, Mr. D. Wilson 4888
Res. 1720, Culture - Comedy Awards (Cdn.): Charlie Rhindress
(Amherst) - Congrats., Hon. E. Fage 4889
Vote - Affirmative 4890
Res. 1721, Econ. Dev. - Ron Roach (Caldwell Roach [Insurance]):
Retirement - Good Wishes, Hon. J. Muir 4890
Vote - Affirmative 4890
Res. 1722, Health - QE II: Cuts - Reconsider, Dr. J. Smith 4891
Res. 1723, Sports - Basketball (Boys Bantam Champs): West Pictou -
Congrats., Mrs. M. Baillie 4891
Vote - Affirmative 4892
Res. 1724, Tourism - Princess Wolfville 2000: Keltie Woodford -
Congrats., Mr. D. Morse 4892
Vote - Affirmative 4893
Res. 1725, Econ. Dev. - C.J. O'Handley Ltd. (Yar.): Anniv. 100th -
Congrats., Mr. R. Hurlburt 4893
Vote - Affirmative 4893
Res. 1726, Sports - Triathlon: Amherst Triathletes (3) -
World Success Acknowledge, Hon. E. Fage 4894
Vote - Affirmative 4894
Res. 1727, Sports - Swimming (Hfx. Invitational Meet 2000):
Michael Nemec (Pt. Hawkesbury) - Success Congrats.,
Mr. Ronald Chisholm 4894
Vote - Affirmative 4895
Res. 1728, Econ. Dev. - Jacques Whitford Environ., Inland Tech. &
Envirosoil: Success (Internat.) - Congrats., Mr. T. Olive 4895
Vote - Affirmative 4896
Res. 1729, Sports - Bowling-Candlepin (N.S. Youth Champs):
Clark's Hbr. Bantam Team - Congrats., Mr. C. O'Donnell 4896
Vote - Affirmative 4897
Res. 1730, Commun. Serv. - E. Preston Day Care Shelley Thomas
Mem. Van: Fund-raising - Success Congrats., Mr. D. Hendsbee 4897
Vote - Affirmative 4897
Res. 1731, Agric. - Dairy Industry: Rupert, Mary & Curtis Boss
(Rodney, Cumb. Co.) - Commitment Congrats.,
(By Mr. W. Dooks) The Speaker 4898
Vote - Affirmative 4898
Res. 1732, Agric. - Farm Safety Day: Bridgeville, Pictou Co. WI -
Sponsorship Commend, Mr. J. DeWolfe 4898
Vote - Affirmative 4899
Res. 1733, Commun. Serv. - Apple Tree Landing Children's Ctr.:
Families (Canning, Kings Co.) - Contribution Recognize,
Mr. M. Parent 4899
Vote - Affirmative 4900
Res. 1734, Lt. Gov. (N.S.) - Hon. J. James Kinley & Hon. Grace Kinley:
Performance Distinguished - Congrats., Hon. M. Baker 4900
Vote - Affirmative 4900
Res. 1735, VON - Anna. Chap.: Service - Commend, Mr. F. Chipman 4901
Vote - Affirmative 4901
Res. 1736, Sports - Athletics (Boston Marathon): Terry Delong
(Chester Area) - Completion Congrats.,
(By Hon. M. Baker) Hon. J. Chataway 4901
Vote - Affirmative 4902
Res. 1737, Sackville-Cobequid MLA - Attendance: Grade -
Fail Issue, Mr. D. Morse 4902
Res. 1738, Health - IWK-Grace Hospital: Kingston RCMP -
Fund-Raising Commend, Mr. J. Carey 4903
Vote - Affirmative 4904
Res. 1739, Sports - Badminton (Mt. Allison Univ. Women):
Rookie of Yr. - Emily Cox (Shel.) Congrats., Mr. C. O'Donnell 4904
Vote - Affirmative 4904
Res. 1740, Environ. - Gaff Pt. (Lun. Co.): Preservationists -
Vision Congrats., Hon. M. Baker 4905
Vote - Affirmative 4905
Res. 1741, Culture - Genealogy: Taylor (James E.) Family (Pictou Co.) -
Reunion, Mr. J. DeWolfe 4905
Vote - Affirmative 4906
ORAL QUESTIONS PUT BY MEMBERS:
No. 620, Educ. - Schools: Equipment Removal - Impact,
Mr. Robert Chisholm 4906
No. 621, Health - Budget (2000-01): Cuts - Impact,
Mr. R. MacLellan 4908
No. 622, Educ. - Prog. Assts.: Elimination - Target,
Ms. Maureen MacDonald 4909
No. 623, Health - Lbr. Readjustment Strategy, Dr. J. Smith 4910
No. 624, Tourism - Budget (2000-01): Peggy's Cove -
Rock Patrollers Cut, Mr. W. Estabrooks 4911
No. 625, Educ.: P3 Schools - Equipment Removal, Mr. W. Gaudet 4912
No. 626, Agric. - Budget (2000-01): Cuts - Changes,
Mr. John MacDonell 4913
No. 627, NSRL - Panuke Field: Sale - Advisor, Mr. R. MacLellan 4914
No. 628, Health - Col. Reg. Hosp.: Cardiac Unit - Closure,
Mr. D. Dexter 4915
No. 629, Health - Mental Health Serv.: Review - Status, Dr. J. Smith 4916
No. 630, Health - Northside & Glace Bay Gen. Hosps.:
Emergency Rooms - Hours Reduction, Mr. F. Corbett 4917
No. 631, Health: S. Shore Reg. Hosp. - Bed Closures, Mr. D. Downe 4918
No. 632, Justice: Dalhousie Legal Aid - Future, Mr. H. Epstein 4919
No. 633, Lbr. - Prov. House: Elevator - Inspect, Mr. R. MacKinnon 4920
No. 634, Health - Addiction Services: Cut - Effect, Ms. E. O'Connell 4922
No. 635, Transport. & Pub. Wks. - Marine Atl.: North Sydney -
Job Losses, Mr. B. Boudreau 4923
No. 636, Lbr. - Safety: Elevators - Priorities, Mr. W. Estabrooks 4924
No. 637, Lbr. - Occup. Health & Safety Regs.: Linesmen -
NSP Include, Mr. R. MacKinnon 4925
No. 638, Commun. Serv. - Soc. Assist.: Rates - Cut, Mr. K. Deveaux 4926
No. 639, Agric. - Programs: Cancelled - Replacements, Mr. D. Downe 4927
No. 640, Commun. Serv. - Child Benefit Prog. (Natl.): Clawback -
Promise Unfulfilled, Mr. K. Deveaux 4928
No. 641, Sysco - Sale: Pensions Fairness - Ensure,
Mr. Manning MacDonald 4930
No. 642, Sysco - Sale: Info. Leak - Inaccurate, Mr. F. Corbett 4931
No. 643, Transport. & Pub. Wks.: Truck Rate (80/20 Provision) -
Continuance, Mr. P. MacEwan 4932
OPPOSITION MEMBERS' BUSINESS:
MOTIONS OTHER THAN GOVERNMENT MOTIONS:
Res. 1592, Health - System: Funding Adequate - Ensure,
Mr. D. Dexter 4933
Mr. D. Dexter 4934
Hon. J. Muir 4936
Dr. J. Smith 4939
Mr. John MacDonell 4942
Res. 982, Human Res. - Pub. Serv.: Non-Privatization - Promise,
Mr. Robert Chisholm 4945
Mr. Robert Chisholm 4945
Hon. R. Russell 4947
Mr. D. Wilson 4950
Ms. E. O'Connell 4952
Hon. G. Balser 4954
ADJOURNMENT:
MOTION UNDER RULE 5C:
Hon. R. Russell 4955
Vote - Affirmative 4956
ADJOURNMENT, House rose to meet again on Thur., May 4th at 12:00 p.m. 4956