Emergency Health Services Nova Scotia

 

EHS Provincial Medical Director

 

CONDUCT & COMPETENCIES COMMITTEE

MINUTES

SATURDAY FEBRUARY 2,2002 & SUNDAY FEBRUARY 3,2002

PRESENT:        Troy, Frizzell (Sun), Erin Froese, Jonathan Pippy, Bruce Cruickshank, Kevin Davison, Gerard Dinn, Ed Cain, Emily Morash and Guest: Bruce Barry

REGRETS:     Wes McCabe,, Barry Tracey, Shelly Valaire, Wes McCabe, Russell Belliveau, JJ MacIsaac , Shane Jewer, John Aucoin, Paul Landriault

ABSENT:     Mike McKeage,

Accepted: April 23,2002


Regular Business Minutes

Due to stormy weather conditions....several members were unable to attend and the arrival of our guest was delayed until Saturday evening.

An informal dinner and function was held Saturday evening at Dr. Cain's home where Members and some spouses and our Guest were able to mingle and chat.(Shelly Valaire,Chairperson and Mike McKeage were also present at this gathering.)

The Regular Business Meeting began at 12:50 on Saturday. Emily Morash/Registrar opened the meeting with Introductions & Welcome to all.

There was one item added to the Agenda.

  • Rumours...C & C issues clarified

The first item for the agenda was acceptance of the December 17,2001 Minutes. A motion to accept was made by Jonathan Pippy and seconded by Erin Froese. Approved by all present.

Item / Discussion Action Person Responsible?
Business Arising: (from last month's Minutes...)

1."Spring Training" - Gerard Dinn gave an update....this was to be an information item about the C&C Committee to be presented to all EHSNS Paramedics to make them aware of what the Committee stands for and it's duties, could possibly be used as a CEU, once completed and as registered members take /watch the course/program /CD-presentation....

Gerard expressed concerns re- time allowance for this now, could someone else take on this responsibility??...he requested volunteers ...Bruce Cruickshank expressed an offer of assistance to help...but would need guidance in this....Gerard and Bruce will continue with the process .

Emily will forward copies of "Due Process Policy" to assist in the compilation of this presentation.

Feedback and input from all Committee members would be appreciated.. ( Contact Gerard or Bruce with these items...check your member's list for contact info... review "Due Process Policy" and Terms of Reference....)

ONGOING Gerard Dinn

Bruce Cruickshank

Emily Morash/Registrar

All Members

2. Committee Member EMD - Posting / Application process

One Application was received for this posted position. A review of the application was made by members present and after a short discussion it was decided by all present to accept Greg MacKinnon as a new member of the Committee.

The Registrar will advise and send information package to the new Member.

YES Emily Morash/ Registrar
3.Time off for Committee Members to attend Meetings? / Dr. Ed Cain

There was concern expresses that some committee members are still having difficulty in getting time off from their employer for scheduled meetings even with sufficient notice being given (ie 3 weeks).

Dr Cain advised he will need specific examples from members in writing...to bring forward to the employer before anything can be dealt with further.

Members are advised to contact Dr. Cain in writing or by e-mail to give specifics as to why/when/ how/ and who was involved....if you are/ were unable to attend a committee Meeting.....

YES Dr. Ed Cain/ Provincial Medical Director

ALL Members

Item / Discussion Action Person Responsible?
Business Arising: (from last month's Minutes...continued)

4. Letters of Reprimand - Response from Colleges ? Emily gave members an update on the responses received from the organizations regarding this.

A discussion took place on.... (Past cases , letters of caution?, future cases, past files to be corrected, permanent letters of reprimand...)

It was decided by all present that past files would be changed /corrected to make the following changes applicable:

"Letter of Caution" - this would could be a temporary reprimand - or for letters on a person's file for a specific period of time.

"Letter of Reprimand" - this would be for a permanant letter of rerimand and it would remain on a members file indefinitely.

However, the member's file could be reviewed on the re-registration date and the member could request a letter from the Committee to advise...."that since the letter has been placed on his/her file there has been no re-occurance of this inappropriate action/behaviour...etc."

Or something to that effect....BUT... to repeat: "The Letter of Reprimand" would remain on the person's file permanently.

The Registrar to go through old case files and make changes.

All Members to clarify in future cases, what type of letter is being placed on a person's file and to review Due Process Policy to initiate this process and make changes to reflect this ...

Ongoing... Yes Emily Morash /Registrar

All Members

5. Terms of Reference - This item was deferred to "Sunday" to discuss however due to lack of time it will be brought forward to the next regularly scheduled meeting.

Also ... Due Process Policy ( to insert definitions too.....)

The Registrar will insure all members have copies sent to them to review before hand....

Ongoing Registrar All Members
Item / Discussion Action Person Responsible?
NEW BUSINESS:

1. Case Reviews - Log Book / Emily Morash - JJ MacIsaac - Dr. E.

Cain

A discussion followed regarding confidentiality .

Only the Chairperson, Registrar and the Provincial Medical Director would be privy to case information. Information regarding cases will be kept in each member's file and recorded in the C & C Log Book. .

All other members of the Committee will be forwarded information on an "as required basis only." for specific cases ( ie only if they are "investigators, on the Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) Panel or the Hearing Panel.

(This issue(s) will also be discussed further during the revision of the Terms of Reference and discussion of changes additions to the "Due Process Policy" at the next regular meeting.)

The format to advise members of present cases was approved by all members present. The Registrar will continue with this new process to advise members using this method in any upcoming Agendas/Minutes.

Ongoing Yes

Ongoing...

All Members Registrar
ADDITIONS TO AGENDA:

1. Rumours...C & C issues clarified / Dr. Ed Cain

A discussion followed with members expressing clarification on what specifically is considered a C&C issue. Is a Committee Member obligated to report any rumours he/she may hear?...What is the duty of the employer to advise the C&C Committee....etc.

This item was discussed further with guest Bruce Barry on Sunday and all agreed that ANY rumours, concerns should be brought to the attention of either the Registrar, the C&C Chairperson or the Provincial Medical Director....Dr. Cain will send letter to employers to advise that it is their responsibility to advise us of conflict issues....and that it is not their own "personnel" issue since EHS is the governing board....union issues are completely separate.

Clarification will be noted in the Terms of Reference and Due Policy Review ...and it was noted that this clarification should be included in the "Spring Training/Information package being initiated " to make all members more aware of what, who, why the Committee is here and How it can assist all members....not just affecting those accused...)

Letter Ongoing Registrar-(to bring forward to next agenda...)

Dr. Ed Cain - (completed...)

All Members

Gerard Dinn

Bruce Cruickshank


There were no other items on the Agenda, so the regular meeting was closed by Ed Cain, Medical Director.

Members will be advised of the date for the next regular meeting.

Information Item from Sunday, February 3,2002

A presentation and question / answer period was given by Guest Speaker : Bruce Barry from Alberta. After this discussion "roles" were assigned and a "Mock Hearing" took place to "walk" members through the process. Mock Hearing Outline

The slide "Presentation" is available on request from the Registrar, Emily Morash. (made available from Bruce Barry in Microsoft Powerpoint format along with pictures...)

After meetings held on February 4& 5,2002 with Dr. Ed Cain, Emily Morash, Registrar and Bruce Barry,(Guest Speaker) it was decided that two (2) hearings would be arranged for March 19 & 20,2002 on the outstanding cases. (Case # 2000.002.1&2 and Case # 2001.007.1)

The Registrar will be responsible for advising Hearing Panel Members and witnesses and the "accused" of these upcoming Official Hearings. She will follow up and organize files, meeting place, times etc. Bruce Barry will assist with forms and procedures used in Alberta.

Due to Hearings being scheduled for March there will be no regularly scheduled meeting in this month. Emily Morash, Registrar will advise members when a meeting date has been arranged this may be tentatively scheduled for late April 2002.

Respectfully submitted,

Emily Morash/ Registrar

E-mail:registrarehs@gov.ns.ca

Attachments

Revised Attendance Sheet 2002 - Feb.19 /02

Revised - C&C Members' Levels & Area List-(To be added to "Terms of Reference"

Revised Members' Contact Information List - Feb.19/02 Agenda - Feb 2 & 3/02 ("Terms of Reference included here...)

Due Process Policy 6006.00

Mock Hearing Outline

Email: caine@gov.ns.ca