|
September 1998
A. Background
Industrial hemp, sometimes referred to as marijuana's
misunderstood cousin, has less than 0.3% THC (the
psycho-active ingredient) whereas the illegal crop
has THC levels ranging much higher. Following a 60-year
ban, it became legal to grow hemp in Canada on April
1, 1998, under license from Health Canada under Bill
C8.
B. Study Objectives
The primary objective of the research is to gather
statistical and market information on industrial hemp
to provide:
- a situational analysis or profile of the industrial
hemp industry in Canada and around the world;
- insight into Maritime opportunities for hemp
production and processing;
- document the economic viability of the crop;
- identify new or emerging value-added opportunities
and challenges that may or may not influence the
competitiveness of a Maritime industry; and,
- provide recommendations concerning the future
development of the industry in the Maritimes.
C. Methodology
C.1 Data Collection
We conducted an extensive literature search and
contacted knowledgeable industry participants and
observers (a contact list is found in Appendix
H).
C.2 Disclaimer
This study relied heavily on information from key
contacts and reports that are publicly available.
It depicts the Canadian hemp industry as of the writing
of this report and to the best of our knowledge based
on available information.
Considerable research, product and market development
is underway that will address many of questions and
issues raised within this paper. Readers are reminded
hemp is in a dynamic stage of development. Which products
and markets, if any, will ultimately prove to be commercially
viable is still an open question. Many government
agriculture personnel agree they have never before
seen the level of hype surrounding a new crop as has
occurred with industrial hemp, Cannabis sativa
L. (hereafter referred to as simply hemp).
D. Hemp in North America: A Brief
Look Over Time
- Hemp has been used as a food grain and as a source of fibre for fish nets, clothing and rope
for thousands of years and is documented as early as 2700 BC in ancient Chinese writings.
- Hemp was so important to the navies of England and the American colonies that farmers
were legislated to dedicate a portion of their farm lands to produce hemp each year. It was
first cultivated in Canada at Port Royal, Nova Scotia, in 1606.
- Hemp was a popular crop in Eastern and Central Canada throughout the 18th and 19th
centuries. The Canadian Department of Agriculture conducted extensive research into the
agronomics, processing and crop improvement across Canada in the 1920s and 1930s.
- Commercial hemp acreage in Canada declined over this period (from a high of 1,640 acres
in 1928 to zero by 1934) due to the high cost of production, strong competition by other fibre
crops produced in the tropics and the emergence of the first synthetic fibres.
- In 1938, the cultivation of Cannabis sativa L. became illegal in Canada under the Opium
and Narcotics Act. In the U.S., the 1937 Marijuana Tax Act banned hemp production in the
U.S. A small amount of production continued during the 1939 to 1945 war period.
- Canadian research into hemp production was re-established in 1994 when Joe Strobel and
Geof Kime of Hempline Inc. in Ontario were granted a research license. To date, only a
handful of states have been granted research licenses in the U.S. (for example, Hawaii and
Vermont) and the crop remains an illegal species for commercial production in all states.
- Hemp research was conducted in Ontario, Manitoba, Saskatchewan and Alberta in 1995
and with the exception of Saskatchewan, again in 1996. In 1997, these same four provinces
as well as Quebec and British Columbia grew hemp on a trial basis.
- 1998 is the first year both research and commercial licenses have been granted in Canada,
thanks to the approval of the new Hemp Regulation under the Controlled Drugs and
Substances Act which was enacted in March 1998. These regulations also apply to the
processing, importing, exporting, sale and the distribution of hemp.
- Hemp has now been planted in all provinces except Newfoundland and Labrador.
- The Health Protection Branch of Health Canada is charged with enforcing legislation
concerning hemp.
- Some of the requirements for a commercial license
include the use of OECD (Organization of Economic
Cooperation and Development), approved seed minimum
acreage (10 acres), a police check of the applicant,
GPS (global positioning system) coordinates of growing
location, sampling and testing, and whether the
crop is to be grown for the fibre and/or seed. Separate
applications are required for each growing season.
E. Production
E.1 World Production
- World production of hemp fibre and tow has fallen from over 300 thousand tonnes in 1961
to 69 thousand tonnes in 1997. China accounts for the lion's share (36%) of production (see
Figures A.1 and A.2 in Appendix A). China, and a number of other major producers, provide
subsides to hemp growers which keep prices artificially high. Yield varies considerably
across countries.
- World hempseed (grain) production fell from 80 thousand tonnes to 37 thousand tonnes
over this same period. Again, China makes up the bulk (73%) of world production (see
Figures A.3 and A.4 in Appendix A). Production in China increased sharply in the
mid-1980s, the influx of grain on the world market depressed prices. A recent report suggests
once China ceased exporting, prices rebounded (Vantreese, 1998).
- Following this long period of decline, production of both fibre and tow and hempseed has
increased in recent years. While the bulk of this occurred in China and France, Eastern
Europe's production has also increased, a function of the end of the ban on hemp cultivation
in the United Kingdom in 1993, in Germany in 1995, increased demand for natural products
by consumers and bio-degradable materials for manufacturing industries and the existence of
substantial farm subsidies.
E.2 Canadian Production in 1998
Canadian hemp cultivation is in its fifth year with 1998 being the first for commercial licenses.
Health Canada is in the process of compiling a complete list of commercial and research licenses
issued in 1998. A report of licenses issued to the end of June 1998 is provided in Appendix A (see Exhibit 1). This information is found, along with license applications, at their websit
(HTTP://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/hpb-dgps/therapeut/htmleng/hemp.htm). Our own research shows at least
5,300 acres have been planted under the research and commercial license issued this year (see
Table1).
About a half dozen companies or consortiums account for the bulk of this production. As such, hemp
production is concentrated in specific areas across Canada but is still composed mainly of small
acreages. Maritime producers account for about 150 acres of the total while a half dozen other groups
together planted over 80% of the total land area in Canada this year. Profiles of the key growers and
processors in the Maritimes and the rest of Canada are found in Appendix B.
| Table 1: 1998 Hemp Production in Canada |
| Prov. |
Known Research and Commercial Licenses |
Acres (1) |
Apparent Mkt |
| BC |
Granby Hemp Co-op (Grand Forks)
Transglobal Hemp Products Corp.(Vancouver Island)
WestHemp Cooperative BC (Lower Mainland)
Canadian Hemp Corp. (Contracts: BC, AB, SK)
Jack Dobb (Dawson Creek) |
27 ac.
approx. 35 ac.
approx. 20 ac.
Unknown
<1 ac. (research) |
Grain,Fibre
Unknown
Unknown
Grain, Fibre
Grain |
| AB |
8-12 commercial growers
Chinook Applied Research Station (SE AB)
1 research license near Edmonton |
150 ac.
20+ ac.
Unknown (research) |
Primarily Grain (oil)
Unknown
Unknown |
| SK |
Western Growers Seed Corporation (mostly organic)
GenEx (several organic growers, Regina) |
approx. 250+ ac.
40 ac. |
Grain, Seed
Seed |
| MB |
Canterra Seeds Ltd. (Winnipeg, 15-20 growers)
Consolidated Growers & Processors (Winnipeg)
Prairie Hemp (40 growers, contracted to Hempola)
HempOil Canada Ltd. (St. Agathe) |
approx. 200 ac.
pprox. 800+ ac.
approx. 500+ ac.
approx. 40 ac. |
Seed
Grain, Fibre
Grain
Unknown |
| ON |
Kenex Ltd. (Pain Court, 54 growers contracted)
Hempline Inc. (London, about 20 growers contracted)
Natural Hemphasis/Six Nations Reserve (Grand R.)
Approximately 30 others (various locations) |
approx. 2,000+ ac.
approx. 500 ac
10 ac. (research)
approx. 300-500 ac. |
Fibre, Grain, Seed
Fibre, Grain
Grain, Fibre
Unknown |
| PQ |
Chanvre Esprit (Michael Gaudreau, organic prod'n)
Orverd (Sylvain Donvierre, Lac St. Jean)
Jerzy Prytyk, Ayers Cliff (assoc. w/GenEx in Regina) |
20 ac.
25 ac.
20 ac. |
Oil, Grain, Fibre, Seed
Fibre
Grain (Oil & Food) |
| NB |
Dr. Chuck Schom (St. Andrews, plots widespread)
NB Department of Agriculture (Fredericton)
Canadian Hemp Company Ltd. (Fredericton)
Al Geddrey (Cambridge Narrows) |
10 ac. (research)
<1 ac. (research)
84 ac. (64 contracted)
10 ac. |
Fibre
Unknown
Undetermined
Fibre, Oil |
| NS |
New Century Farms (Billtown, Kings Co.)
Don Hunter (Pugwash area)
NS Department of Agriculture & Marketing (Truro) |
11 ac.
13 ac.
<1 ac. (research) |
Fibre
Fibre initially
Fibre, Grain |
| PE |
Maurice Van Daele/Island Hemp Co. (Pt. Pleasant) |
17 ac. (research) |
Fibre, Grain |
| NF |
No production |
0 ac. |
- |
|
Total |
approx. 5,300+ ac. |
|
must wait until at least 1999 before there are opportunities
to rigorously test the suitability of available oilseed varieties to Maritime conditions.
We have prepared responses to a set of market potential questions that are based on the findings of
this section. These are found in Table F.1 in Appendix F. A glossary of hemp industry terms has been
provided in Appendix G. Appendix H lists the individuals contacted as part of the research for this
study.
J. Overcoming the Obstacles to Growth
The results of the last section suggest a number of obstacles must be overcome before widespread
development can occur in the Maritimes, or for that matter, the rest of Canada. These are described
below.
J.1 Better Understanding of the Technological Hurdles
- Hand-cutting is a traditional method in low-wage countries but considered impractical for
large-scale production. Mechanized harvesting can be done but it is very rough on machinery
because hemp easily wraps itself around revolving parts. Development and testing of
harvesting technology to Canadian conditions is still on-going with some prototypes only
becoming recently available.(12)
- Processing technologies are generally regarded as antiquated and there is a need to adapt
current technology from other fibre crops (such as flax) to commercial field production of
hemp. Some industry experts opine economical processing infrastructure will be several
years in the making.
- No processing facilities are available in the Maritimes even as we approach plant maturity.
J.2 Access to Seed and Appropriate Varieties Developed for Local Conditions
- There is limited certifiable (OECD), low-THC seed and fewer seed-bred cultivars are
climatized for Canada.(13) Seed multiplication may help curb this demand but varieties need to be developed for Canadian conditions. Many of the European cultivars are bred for fibre and
not oilseed production. Environmental conditions necessary for seed production are said to
be more favourable in areas outside of the Maritimes.
- Present members of the Canadian Seed Growers Association are expected to pursue this
market. They have the experience, know the regulations and procedures and have the
cleaning equipment required. While several hemp growers and processors are positioning
themselves for the pedigreed seed market, it can take decades to develop new varieties.
J.3 Access to Information and Expertise
- While a number of well attended Canadian hemp symposiums and published government
research have broadened the information base for this new crop, much proprietary
management and technological expertise is being developed.(14) Indeed, a number of projects
are cloaked under non-disclosure agreements between government and private industry. This
will impede growth of the Maritime industry to some degree.
- According to one contact, while partnering arrangements with other key Canadian players
can assist in information transfer, the Maritimes needs to be at the forefront of research,
development and testing if we are to successfully and economically penetrate the hemp
market.
J.4 Biophysical Conditions
- It is unclear the extent to which biophysical variations in the Maritimes will tend to
concentrate production and therefore processing facilities. Given the observed success of at
least one grower, we know hemp can be grown, although yields will only become apparent
following the harvest.
- A study by Sara Francis entitled, "Hemp (Cannabis sativa L.) as an Alternative Fibre
Source for Nova Scotia" suggests Nova Scotia has soils deemed as only fair to poor for hemp
growing (based on soil conditions and based on major limitations in slope and depth). This
may also contribute to concentrated areas of production and processing.
J.5 Competition
- Hemp has a number of competing fibre alternatives for major fibre markets. For example,
in 1997, farmers in Western Canada seeded 1.8 million acres of oilseed flax and over 200
thousand acres of edible oilseed flax (solin) with a total production of about 1.25 million
tonnes of flax straw. Nearly a million tonnes of straw will be sold for $6 to $9 per tonne,
burned or simply left in the field. Given the value-added potential and the need to reduce
environmentally unfriendly practices, there is pressure to find markets for the flax straw.
Given the earlier arguments made for only niche market specialty papers, fibre markets will
require considerable development before they can support large-scale commercial
production.
- Maritime producers have only just entered a market in which several major players have
some lead. Whereas some of the key players have focused on particular markets that do not
overlap, Maritime growers are to some degree chasing the same markets in the region and
will compete with larger players at the national level. Economics and market positioning will
be vital to success.
J.6 Markets and Marketing
- Many independent growers are still in the process of developing markets for this year's
crop. This suggests primary processors will likely play a key role in developing markets and
that at present, the market is not structured for large scale and long-term growth.
- Contrary to many reports, hemp is at present a niche market. Increasing demand for hemp
products over the last decade has not yet fueled an increase in world production of fibre and
grain. Furthermore, there are limited markets for this year's production, although some key
players are said to have markets secured. Expanding the range of value-added industrial
products available and fostering the necessary consumer demand will take time.
- Careful product positioning and advertising for consumer awareness will be important to
success in the higher-value oil and food markets. To quote one respondent, "the sizzle sells
the steaks". Growers must understand that while infrastructure investment tends to be less
than that required for fibre markets, considerable working capital is needed to launch a new
product into the health market.
- One respondent suggested there is a danger in trying to pursue hemp in too large a scale
for the Maritimes. Local uses and niche markets should be the focus initially suggesting a
"get there first" situation versus unlimited demand.
J.7 Vertical Integration
- This is considered by many to be blueprint for success in hemp. The fibre market, the
primary focus of Maritime growers, is not one where one individual farmer is likely to
develop given the volume that is needed to economically sustain processing facilities. For
example, HempFlax in the Netherlands complements its large growing base (over 5,500
acres) with two decorticating plants and a recently purchased a paper mill with an annual
capacity of 30 thousand tons of paper (25% hemp composition). The company has spent
millions developing harvesting and processing machinery.
- Primary processors should consider contracting
hemp production to guarantee price and consistency
of supply.
J.8 Partnering
- There appears to be opportunities for partnering both within and outside the Maritimes. We
are aware Maritime growers have been networking with each other and with major players,
to varying degrees of success. Given the level of partnering that is already occurring within
the industry, Maritime growers and processors will need to develop a critical mass for
production, marketing and distribution channels and partnering may be the key to quickly
gaining a leg-hold in the industry.
- Partnering with other key players in the industry
will also help to transfer expertise between growers,
processors, manufacturers and retailers.
J.9 Price Uncertainty
- There is much price uncertainty in thin markets where the volume of trading is low. The
degree to which production can increase without affecting prices is not known. Growers and
processors need to do their homework on the economics and market potential of hemp. As
production comes on line, prices will fall unless growing demand for hemp products outstrips
supply.
- It is important to keep in mind that as subsidies in Europe are further reduced and phased
out, the true economics of hemp will appear. If they are poor, world production may decline
and this could act as a boon for Canadian producers.
J.10 Quality
- Quality is a key determinant for market success, especially for use in textiles. While
quality from some countries can be highly variable, low and medium wage countries tend
produce some of the best quality hemp products such as fabrics. Maritime growers must be
keenly aware of market specifications and ensure standards are maintained.
J.11 Quantity
- Given the need for economies of scale, growers and processors will need to ensure they
provide a consistent and adequate supply of raw and processed hemp if the industry is to
attain the necessary critical mass. Key players in the industry have accomplished this through
contracting and guaranteed pricing mechanisms.
J.12 Regulatory Environment
- The 1998 hemp licensing process was frustrating for many growers and processors. Many
were given the go-ahead late in the season but seeded anyway. It is unclear how licensing
may change or the extent to which hurdles encountered during the 1998 season may pave the
way for next year's licensing procedures. It is imperative interested growers do their
homework to ensure a smooth licensing process.
J.13 Testing Facilities
- THC-testing is a mandatory requirement for licensing. A number of testing laboratories are
found across Canada but none have been established in the Maritimes. This should be
addressed if the industry experiences rapid growth. We understand the Nova Scotia
Agriculture College is examining the potential for becoming a licensed testing facility. The
PEI Food and Technology Centre may also be a potential candidate.
K. Conclusions and Recommendations for Industry Direction
K.1 Conclusions
- World production of hemp fibre and tow and hemp grain has followed a long period of
decline. Increased demand for hemp products over the last decade has not yet fuelled an
increase in world production of fibre and grain. Volumes of imported hemp raw fibre and
manufactured goods into Canada are small.
- It is clear a culture of believers in hemp and its variety of uses has developed in North
America. This is reflected in the growth of hemp-based products, all based on imports of
hemp fibre, grain and oil. Some individuals within the agricultural community have observed
this and believe there is an opportunity to supply this demand with domestically produced
hemp fibre and grain.
- The markets for hemp products can best be described as developing. They are primarily a
loosely connected set of niche markets. This industry is in its infancy, having lain dormant
on the supply-side in North America for 60 years.
- Despite the high degree of interest in hemp, little or no hemp has been sold by Canadian
processors to date. The first sales will occur when the approximately 5,300 acres are
harvested and processed this year. Only then will the there be a demonstration of the real
market potential of various hemp products. By next spring, the potential markets should be
substantially better defined.
- This study was aimed at identifying the potential for a Maritime-wide industry. Maritime
production is small, made up of only a handful of growers. In the absence of a
well-developed distribution system, there appears to exist only niche-market opportunities
for a small number of growers. Our research suggests that at this time substantial effort will
be required to develop a Maritime industry for many of the markets claimed for hemp
products such as textiles, building materials, alcoholic beverages, livestock feed, bedding and
biomass fuels. The main reasons include insufficient processing and value-added
infrastructure and incomplete research and development results.
- There appears to be some potential for oil production if both the agronomic and economic
feasibility can be demonstrated and local cold press crushing facilities are established. The
heath food market also offers some potential. However, testing oilseed viability cannot occur
before 1999 given limited production and the fibre-focus of Maritime growers this season.
- If the interest reportedly expressed by Minas Basin Pulp & Power Co. in using hemp fibre
in its paperboard products is confirmed, this may be the best example of a concrete market in
the Maritimes for hemp.
K.2 Recommendations
The priorities for the departments of agriculture in the Maritimes appear to be:
- Monitor the production, processing and marketing of fibre, grain and seed across Canada.
- Monitor the regulatory system.
- Acquire and test as many varieties as possible from European, Canadian and plant
breeders.
- As market opportunities become clearer, the direction for testing, whether it be for fibre or
grain varieties, will become evident as will the need to maximize yields under Maritime
conditions and management schemes.
- Prepare and provide to growers and processors a summary of the information in this report
and include any agronomic reports completed over this fall and winter. The information
should be provided no later than the spring of 1999.
- Research and information dissemination should be supported rather than investment into
infrastructure, given the immaturity and uncertainty of the markets for hemp.
Footnotes
1.
Industrial Hemp: Global Operations, Local Implications, July 1998, Valerie L. Vantreese, Department of
Agricultural Economics, University of Kentucky.
2.
Hemp Entrepreneurs and U.S. Public Policy: The 1996 Hemp Business Survey, July, 1996, John Gettman.
3.
Kenex Ltd. is attempting to secure long-term growing contracts from farmers while pursuing long-term
market contracts with buyers such as General Motors of Canada. They deduct the costs of management,
harvesting, retting, baling, etc., from this price unless the grower assures responsibility for these activities.
4.
In comparison, 1995 estimates for growing costs for hemp for fibre and hurds ranged from $268 to $285
per acre. Growing hemp for seed was estimated to cost $238 per acre. Source: Gordon Reichert, Market
Analysis Division, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, 1996 Crop Budgets 1995, Publication #60,
OMAFRA.
5.
The net returns from growing hemp for fibre are estimated to be between $100 and $300/acre, depending
on the growing region and the management practices. More accurate data is expected by January, 1999.
Source: Mike Columbus, OMAFRA.
6.
The Bank of Montreal has recently announced a Sponsored Advertising Program whereby they pay for
advertising costs in Commercial Hemp Magazine. Companies must be in the start-up phase (less than one
year). For more information, requests can be faxed to 604-662-8621 or e-mailed to
wisesale@wisenoble.com (the publisher of the magazine).
7.
Source: G. N. Chaudhary, Special Products Team of Alberta Agriculture, Food and Rural Development in
Alberta Hemp Symposium Proceedings in Red Deer, (March 10) and Edmonton (April 8, 1998).
8.
In 1996, Alcell Technologies, a subsidiary of Repap Enterprises, experimented with pulping both wheat
straw and whole hemp stalks. Alcell Technologies Inc. is a patented process that pulps hardwood, annual
fibres and agriculture residues. The process is said to result in product yields of 76% to 86%, compared
with conventional pulping processes yielding 51%. Sale of the company put the project on hold. A news
release posted March 2, 1998 at the Pacific Rim website indicated Malaspina Capital Ltd. was at the time
negotiating with Repap Enterprises Ltd. to purchase shares in Alcell Technologies Inc. and stated there is
enormous potential for the technology in Asia and other international markets. Currently, there is an idle
demonstration plant at Atholville, New Brunswick.
9.
We have been unable to confirm these reports with the company.
10.
It is important to note corrugated cardboard does not require the same level of processing as that of higher
grade papers produced by many of the other Maritime mills.
11.
As found on the website for the Washington Hemp Education Network (WHEN) located at
HTTP://www.olywa.net/when/secto1.html.
12.
Tilby Systems Ltd., of Victoria, BC has a long history in sugarcane, kanaf and sweet sorghum fibre
separation techniques. They are awaiting green hemp stalk to test the viability of using existing equipment
to determine what modifications, if any, are needed for hemp. Another piece of machinery, The Tornado,
marketed by Bolton-Emerson Americas Inc. of Massachusetts, has been developed to process non-wood
fibres into papermaking material. While there are conflicting reports as to its effectiveness, the
non-plugging machine is said to accommodate plants directly from the field and processes them into a
homogenized fibre slurry by subjecting the fibre to repeated scissors-lime action thereby cutting the fibres
into shorter lengths. Another piece of machinery, the Chaflin, then refines the pumpable slurry into
papermaking stock. This has potential to eliminate the need to cook the slurry. For more information, visit
their website at HTTP://www.papermaking.com/tpmc/addeck/bolteme.htm.
13.
There are 26 approved cultivars in Canada for 1998. Kenex Ltd. has reported there is seed left over from
this season as orders were reduced due to delays in licensing. Furthermore, seed prices are expected to fall
by 10-15% in 1999.
14.
For example, the following statement can be found on the Kenex Ltd. website: We have compiled a great
deal of knowledge, expertise and technology at a very high cost over the last several years. Much of the
information has been provided to the public at no charge but we hope you understand we must maintain
some proprietary information in order to create a sustainable business.
|